Thursday, December 18, 2008

Math and Computers

At Thurston, the algebra students go to the computer lab twice a week where they work on practice problems. Apparently the district purchased an entire curriculum that is computer based. The students also have a textbook written by the same people that produce the computer program, which they work out of the three days of the week they are in the classroom. I noticed something interesting the other day while I was in the lab that made me wonder if the program was worthwhile. Along with completing the problems on the computer, the students were also hand writing some of them out on paper. I asked my mentor about it and she said was noticing that students were not doing so well on hand-written tests when they had previously aced similar problems on the computer. I guess she felt some learning was lost by not actually writing the problem down instead of just typing numbers into a computer. It made me curious about how much learning takes place when pencil hits paper and a student physically solves a problem by hand. I think it makes sense to me as I always remember things better if I write them down but then what is the point of the computers? Why not just stay in class and work on problems? Well I suppose students like to get out of class every so often and, maybe, they are more apt to be motivated if working with computers. I mean who doesn't love computers. I have been in MAC for six months and constantly see entire classes of grad students typing away on their computers. They are cool. So I guess if it makes them want to learn, its alright. But it seems kinda silly to write the problem too. But hey as long as the students are engaged and learning, what's there to complain about?

2 comments:

Jeff Stanzler said...

It's an interesting question, isn't it? How much of it is habit (it took me a couple of years before I was able to compose anything serious without writing it out in longhand first) and how much of it corresponds to the way in which we learn best? For that matter, even if it *is* "just habit," does it matter if it impedes student learning?
This is something that will be very interesting for you to watch, Chris.

Rebekah said...

I would also be interested to see what people say about learning and assessment. If you teach via computer, does that mean you should assess in the same fashion? Just because a student can explain acceleration to me in words in class, doesn't mean he can get a multiple choice question correct even if it is the same idea.
Which seems strange to me but I suppose that is just how people work.
(-: