Friday, October 17, 2008

EduBlogger and 9/11

While I was looking at edublogger posts I found one that made me feel old, sad and determined at the same time. This particular edublogger, Doug, wrote a post entitled "The Memory Hole," about his 11-12 year old students who had difficulty remembering anything about 9/11. They were about four in 2001 so I can't really blame them for not having clear memories about that day. But the quote that really caught my attention was when one student asked, "Why do we have to talk about this every year?" Obviously, someone has failed to explain to this student how the world is affected by this single event. I think Doug summarized the impact of not comprehending 9/11 nicely when he wrote, "How can we understand Al-Qaeda? Osama bin Laden? airport security? the war on terrorism? Afghanistan? the Patroit Act provisions, or the war in Iraq?"

This situation also made me think about Pearl Harbor, which has more significance to those people who lived through it. Whereas, I learned about it in school from a textbook. There is almost an emotional detachment for me, in the sense that the event is like a story I would read or a movie (damn you Ben Affleck!). The problem is we are living the post 9/11 history right now, so there are no textbooks for this next generation to learn from. The history is still writing itself. So how are the students who were too young to remember 9/11 going to get the relevant information? How can they understand much of their world is shaped by a single day? Well, those people who remember 9/11 are going to have to make sure that younger students grasp the significance of the event. But teachers should shoulder most the responsibility because, well, that is our job.

For the next generation to understand the world they live in, they must know about past events. Especially, relatively recent events like 9/11. I hope teachers don't take for granted that their students know or feel the same way they do about history. Meaning, if we don't explain topics like this to them, who will?

http://borderland.northernattitude.org/

3 comments:

Scott and Kristen said...

It is hard to understand how someone, even young kids, would not comprehend the significance of 9/11. You are right, it is the responsibility of parents, teachers and the community to teach its importance to students. However, there are actually some textbooks that discuss 9/11. My US History classes got a new textbook this year and it goes all the way up until the midterm elections in 2006! So it discusses the importance of 9/11, the War in Afghanistan and the War in Iraq. It was so weird the first time I saw that chapter because I could not believe I was old enough to have events that I clearly remember put into textbooks!

Stephanie V said...

This is totally trippy - to be confronted with the fact that what happened in your lifetime is now considered history. Every once in a while this thought crosses my mind, but it's still so weird to think about. When I had to do interview projects in high school where I had to ask my parents about the 70s or my grandparents about the 50s, they all said it was weird, and now I am beginning to understand why. We're getting old I guess. Before you know it, we'll be hearing 50 cent on the oldies station. Oh, the horror!

Jeff Stanzler said...

Your post (and Kristen and Stephanie's responses) had me thinking about opportunities. Might there be some interesting ways suggested by your posting to engage students in dealing with issues of perspective? Writing a letter to a kid who's in HS in 2028, explaining how *they* are thinking about/trying to make sense of a current event, the Obama election, 9-11, etc.
Hmmm...I need to think some more about this.